Wednesday, August 10, 2022
HomeA FocusCMS coy on why it prematurely terminated probe into Bonitas

CMS coy on why it prematurely terminated probe into Bonitas

BonitasNew questions have been raised by Business Day about the Council for Medical Schemes' decision in 2018 inexplicably to terminate a two-year investigation into allegations of trustee election fraud, improper contracts and conflicts of interest at Bonitas, SA’s second-largest open medical scheme. The independent investigator, prematurely pulled from the job, noted an "orchestrated effort" at the CMS to derail his work.

The CMS initiated the investigation, which is called an “inspection” in terms of the Medical Schemes Act, into Bonitas in November 2014. Bonitas then launched legal action opposing the inspection that went as far as the Supreme Court of Appeal. The inspection eventually got under way in late 2016, before being halted.

Business Day reports that it has seen draft inspection report into the affairs of Bonitas, compiled by independent investigator Dennis Mayaba, who was prematurely pulled from the job.

Bonitas last week threatened to interdict Business Day from publishing aspects of the draft inspection report. The newspaper has agreed not to publish allegations levelled against Bonitas at this stage, as it is incomplete, by the inspector’s admission.

However,Business Day says, it can reveal that in his report Mayaba says he faced “significant challenges in obtaining co-operation, support and information from certain representatives of the CMS” during the course of his inspection, and that he was instructed to stop working on the probe before it was complete. He was unable to interview Bonitas employees, executives and trustees.

Mayaba submitted a draft report to the CMS on October 12 2018, drawing attention to the premature termination of his work. “It is disconcerting that there seems to be an orchestrated effort by certain individuals at the regulator to derail the processes described in the Act,” wrote Mayaba, referring to the Medical Schemes Act. The report says he declined to comment when approached, referring queries to the CMS.

The CMS is charged with safeguarding consumers’ interests and ensuring schemes play by the rules, but, the report says, its unexplained halting of a probe on such serious allegations raises questions about the nature of the regulator’s relationship with the R180bn industry it oversees.

Bonitas has 720,000 beneficiaries and is administered by Medscheme, which is owned by a subsidiary of JSE-listed Afrocentric Group.

The report says earlier in 2019, the CMS suspended Stephen Mmatli, the head of investigations and compliance, pending the outcome of an inquiry into alleged corruption on his part. The CMS also faces a probe by the Special Investigating Unit, which awaits a proclamation from the president before it gets under way.

The CMS confirmed that it had received Mayaba’s draft report, but declined to explain why the inspection had been aborted, or indicate who gave the instruction to do so. When asked what action it had taken in response to Mayaba’s claim – levelled four months ago – that his work had effectively been interfered with by the CMS, spokesperson Grace Khoza is quoted in the report as saying: “The report is currently being processed internally and we cannot respond to this question at this time.”

Bonitas principal officer Gerhard van Emmenis said the scheme had received the draft report from the CMS on 14 January but had yet to formulate its response to the regulator. He said he was aware the inspection had been prematurely terminated but did not know why. “We have directed an enquiry to the regulator, but have not yet heard back,” van Emmenis is quoted in the report as saying.

Bonitas has a solvency ratio of 25%, and reported a surplus of R730.2m in 2017, indicating it is in strong financial health, according to a statement issued by the scheme two weeks ago. A scheme’s solvency ratio is the ratio of accumulated funds to annualised gross contributions, and is required by the Medical Schemes Act to be at least 25%.

See also
[link url="https://www.medicalbrief.co.za/archives/cms-probed-maladministration-corruption/"]CMS to be probed for maladministration and corruption[/link]

[link url="https://www.businesslive.co.za/bd/national/2019-02-25-medical-body-mum-on-bonitas-probe/"]Business Day report[/link]

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Receive Medical Brief's free weekly e-newsletter.

* indicates required