Monday, August 8, 2022
HomeSouth AfricaUnions criticise Netcare's 'premature' retrenchment plans

Unions criticise Netcare's 'premature' retrenchment plans

Hospital group Netcare plans to retrench over 500 employees as it seeks to cut costs following a failed offshore expansion and amid a tough economic environment in South Africa. The Times reports that group employment relations manager Ramasela Mokonyama confirmed that section 189 notices had been issued to inform staff that the company would begin consultations on the "proposed structural review within its hospital division".

No nurses working in patient care are included in the retrenchment process, which the company said was restricted to staff employed in other divisions.

Mokonyama said: "516 Netcare employees received a letter informing them of the company's intention to review their conditions of employment, (but) the vast majority of employees will be consulted regarding proposed amendments to their current hours of work or current roles." The report says the number of posts to be potentially made redundant will not exceed 0.7% of the 20,000 Netcare staff.

Kevin Halama, public relations officer at the Health & Other Services Personnel Trade Union of SA (Hospersa) said: "Netcare has consistently raked in millions of rands in South Africa’s heavily monopolised private hospital industry, where it is the market leader. The group's intentions to retrench employees will leave many families without breadwinners in a country where unemployment has reached alarming levels, and this we cannot allow."

The Democratic Nursing Organisation of SA (Denosa) called Netcare's proposal premature, saying it had not explored alternatives to saving jobs.

The report says in March 2018 Netcare sold its controlling stake in BMI Healthcare in the UK over a failed lease agreement.

Wayne McCurrie of FNB Wealth & Investments said the tough situation Netcare found itself in was reflective of industry-wide issues. "It's not just South Africa, it's worldwide – you can look at Mediclinic's operations in Switzerland, at their operation in the Middle East, in the Dubai area – governments are trying to get the costs of medicines and care down. It's tough out there." McCurrie said the pressure from governments was likely to remain, as they would continue to legislate, putting pressure on hospitals' operations.

The report says hospital groups are not the only part of the health industry that face limited growth in a mature market. Medical aid schemes are also bearing the brunt of stagnant growth as the number of insured lives has stayed flat at 8.8m since 2014.


Hospersa has criticised the move, reports Fin24, and has vowed to use all its legal avenues to block any possible retrenchments.

"We reject the reasons given by Netcare for the possible retrenchments," said Hospersa public relations officer Kevin Halama in the report. "The group's intentions to retrench employees will leave many families without bread winners in a country where unemployment has reached alarming levels, and this we cannot allow."


Denosa says it’s saddened by the decision to retrench 189 of its employees in its hospital division. Eyewitness News quotes Denosa as saying it’s received confirmation that 189 employees will be retrenched.

“If they think we’re not supposed to enter this terrain of even commenting about it… we’re talking about human beings who face retrenchment. When they approach the CCMA to facilitate this process of retrenchment, Denosa will be there in full force,” says Denosa's acting general secretary, Cassim Lekhoathi.

[link url="–facing-the-chop/"]The Times report[/link]
[link url=""]Fin24 report[/link]
[link url=""]Eyewitness News report[/link]

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Receive Medical Brief's free weekly e-newsletter.

* indicates required